HR Retainers vs Ad-Hoc Support - Which Model Works for Your Business?

CIPD research: 77% of UK small businesses lack dedicated HR support, yet spend 15-20 hours monthly on people management. With HR problems costing UK SMEs an estimated £8,000 annually (Simply Business), the question isn't whether you need HR expertise—it's how to access it cost-effectively.

The UK Context:

FSB data: Employment and tax regulations are the top concern for 64% of small businesses. With 65+ employment law changes in 2023 and the Employment Rights Bill 2024 promising major shake-ups, keeping compliant whilst running your business is near-impossible alone.

Your UK Options:

Ad-Hoc/Project-Based: Pay for specific advice or projects as needed. No commitment.Monthly Retainer: Fixed monthly fee for agreed hours/services. Ongoing relationship.Fractional/Interim: Part-time HR resource working set days. Acts as your HR function.

UK Cost Comparison:

Ad-Hoc Support (Typical UK Rates)

• Hourly rate: £85-£150+ (London £120-150, regions £85-120)
• Half-day: £400-£650
• Full-day: £750-£1,200
• Tribunal preparation: £1,500-£3,000
• Policy creation: £800-£1,500
• Dismissal support: £600-£1,200

Reality check: Three hours monthly ad-hoc = £3,060-£5,400 annually vs £3,600-£7,200 retainer with more comprehensive support.

Monthly Retainer (UK Market Rates)

• 10-30 employees: £300-£500 monthly (£3,600-£6,000 annually)
• 30-80 employees: £500-£800 monthly (£6,000-£9,600 annually)
• 80-150 employees: £800-£1,200 monthly (£9,600-£14,400 annually)

Includes: 3-6 hours monthly, unlimited email/phone advice, legislative updates, policy reviews, templates, priority response.

Fractional/Interim (UK Day Rates)

• 1 day weekly: £400-£650/day (£1,600-£2,600 monthly)
• 2 days weekly: £3,200-£5,200 monthly
• 3 days weekly: £4,800-£7,800 monthly

Compare to UK Internal Hire:

• HR Manager salary: £35,000-£45,000 (£42,000 average, £48,000 London)
• Employer NI (13.8%): £4,830-£6,210
• Pension (3%): £1,050-£1,350
• Recruitment: £3,000
• Total: £44,380-£57,060+

Retainer alternative: £6,000-£9,600 = 85-89% saving

When Ad-Hoc Makes Sense:

Your situation:

• Under 15 employees
• Stable workforce, minimal turnover
• Strong management team
• Limited budget (under £500 monthly)
• Specific, infrequent needs

Advantages:

• Pay only when needed
• Access specialists
• No commitment
• Budget control

Disadvantages:

• Reactive approach
• Higher hourly costs
• Consultant lacks business context
• May wait for availability
• No proactive compliance alerts

When Retainers Make Sense:

Your situation:

• 20-100 employees
• Regular HR questions (2+ monthly)
• Want proactive compliance
• Prefer relationship with consultant
• Quick access without watching clock

Advantages:

• Predictable monthly cost
• Proactive support prevents risks
• Quick response (same/next day)
• Consultant understands your business
• Legislative updates automatic
• 40-60% cheaper than ad-hoc for regular needs

Disadvantages:

• Monthly commitment (3-12 months)
• May not use all hours some months
• Still need budget for major projects

ACAS data: Businesses with regular HR support face 60% fewer employment disputes. One tribunal claim (£25,000+ average) exceeds 3-4 years of retainer fees.

When Fractional Makes Sense:

Your situation:

• 80-150 employees
• Significant daily HR workload
• Building HR function
• Major transformation
• Rapid growth requiring strategic HR

Advantages:

• Dedicated resource
• Handles strategic and operational
• 40-60% saving vs full-time
• Flexible—scale as needed
• Multi-business experience

Disadvantages:

• Higher monthly cost (£3,200-£7,800)
• Not daily presence
• May still need specialists for tribunals

The Hybrid Approach (Popular UK Model):

Model 1: Retainer + Ad-Hoc

• Monthly retainer (£400-600) for compliance and advice
• Ad-hoc for major projects
• Example: 35-person retail pays £500 monthly, used £2,000 for redundancy. Total: £8,000 vs £12,000-15,000 all ad-hoc.

Model 2: Fractional + Specialist

• Fractional HR 1-2 days weekly for strategic/operational
• Employment law solicitor for tribunal risk
• Example: 120-person logistics uses 1-day weekly (£1,800) plus law retainer (£200). Total: £24,000 vs £55,000+ full-time.

Decision Framework:

Calculate current HR costs:

• Management time: ___ hours monthly × £50-100
• Ad-hoc advice last 12 months: £___
• Recruitment costs (poor hiring): £___
• Absence management: £___
• Total annual HR cost: £___

Assess UK-specific risk:

High risk (consider retainer/fractional):

• High turnover (>15% annually)
• Complex workforce (shifts, zero-hours, contractors)
• Previous tribunal claims
• Rapid growth (15%+ headcount)
• Upcoming redundancies or TUPE

Medium risk (retainer likely beneficial):

• Moderate turnover (8-15%)
• Some complexity
• Occasional performance issues
• Steady growth (5-15%)

Lower risk (ad-hoc may suffice):

• Low turnover (<8%)
• Stable, simple contracts
• Strong management
• Minimal growth

The Employment Rights Bill 2024 Impact:

Coming changes significantly increase tribunal risk:

• Day-one unfair dismissal
• Day-one sick pay
• Predictable hours
• Enhanced parental leave
• Fire and rehire restrictions

Retainer support helps adapt policies proactively rather than reactively after claims.

The Bottom Line:

Choose Ad-Hoc if: Under 20 employees, stable workforce, infrequent needs, budget under £500 monthly.

Choose Retainer if: 20-100 employees, regular questions (2+ monthly), want proactive compliance, budget £300-800 monthly.

Choose Fractional if: 80-200 employees, need strategic HR leadership, building function, budget £1,600-5,000 monthly.

Choose Hybrid if: 30-120 employees, variable needs, want cost optimisation, budget £500-2,000 monthly.

Cost-Benefit Reality:

• Average UK tribunal claim cost: £25,000-£40,000
• Average annual retainer: £6,000-£9,600
• ROI: Preventing one claim pays for 3-4 years of support

ACAS research shows businesses with regular HR support are:

• 60% less likely to face tribunals
• 45% more likely to resolve disputes informally
• 38% more efficient handling employee issues

‍

Your Action Plan:

1. Calculate current HR costs
2. Assess your risk level
3. Identify actual needs
4. Get quotes for different models
5. Check credentials (CIPD, insurance, references)
6. Trial period (3-6 months)
7. Review regularly

The question isn't whether you can afford HR support. It's whether you can afford not to have it.

Sign up to Link into HR Consulting today to match to the right HR specialist who can support you with choosing between HR retainers vs ad-hoc support.‍